Blog Archive

Showing posts with label Arab. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arab. Show all posts

The limits of social media in understanding protests



Above is the tweeting intensity for geo-tagged tweets coming from the protest site in Athens. Though the number rises and falls with major events on the ground, Athens generally has low levels of tweeting.



Compare this to a protest site in Barcelona Spain. Though the crowds in Athens are as bigger if not bigger than those in Spain the levels of tweeting in Spain are far higher than in Greece.

Levels of tweeting vary wildly between cultures. Greeks are less likely to tweet with mobile smartphones than Spanish. This can be in part accounted for by income. But also do not forget that Greeks could quickly start tweeting in the way Arab have since the Arab Awakening.

A very key thing to remember is that Greeks don't need to tweet. Why, well here are some key observations:

  • Protests in Greece are more organized, they involve more established groups within civil society like trade unions. They have the ability to organize and communicate that pre-date twitter.
  • Protest in Greece are more acknowledged by the local and global media. One interesting fact is that Greek protesters have been flashing green laser light at the press core. The explanation I hear is that the protesters are not happy with the way the events are covered in the Greek press. Outside of Greece the global media has paid huge amounts of attention to Greece. In Spain many of the acompada protesters felt they were being ignored. In Bahrain people felt as though the global media had ignored them. In these cases people who feel neglected by established media will turn to new media to try and get the message out. This neglect of protests is not a case in Greece, where every action of the Greek protests is carried live around the world.
  • Protests in Greece contain a larger band of age demographics. Unlike Spain the Greek protests have drawn people from almost every demographic in the country. And unlike Egypt Greece is a European country with an older population. Therefore a large part of the demonstrations are people are not digital natives.
  • Protests have often been violent. Though there are debates of who started the fighting Greece protests have seen more confrontation. Tweeting is generally more active in large peaceful protests.

Tracking real time tweeting in major Arab cities



Beirut is the city closest to Syria, has the strongest ties, and has the most to gain or lose from the situation in Syria and we anticipate high tweeting the city today.



Tahrir as the de facto Capital of the Jasmine Revolt and the site of pro-democracy protests ongoing. In Cairo scores of over 80 are very high.



Kuwait is a major hub for tweeting and it will be interesting to see if levels raise above their normal highs in the 80s.



Tweeting in Bahrain has fallen massively since the crack down, on a combination of arrests and state terror along with protesters on twitter learning to use identity hiding systems like Tor.

Tracking Friday Tweeting levels in Arab World



Beirut is the city closest to Syria, has the strongest ties, and has the most to gain or lose from the situation in Syria and we anticipate high tweeting the city today.



Tahrir as the de facto Capital of the Jasmine Revolt and the site of pro-democracy protests ongoing. In Cairo scores of over 80 are very high.



Kuwait is a major hub for tweeting and it will be interesting to see if levels raise above their normal highs in the 80s.



Tweeting in Bahrain has fallen massively since the crack down, on a combination of arrests and state terror along with protesters on twitter learning to use identity hiding systems like Tor.


We are starting to see how tweeting may reflect a fundamental set of human rights. When a community like Bahrain's Shia's suddenly stop tweeting we can safely assume that repression of one form is being exercised against them. On the other hand if a community starts tweeting on a sustained level like the people of Cairo we can hope that new freedoms of expression being exercised.

Again twitter is just a tool. Its use needs to be linked back to bigger social processes that are forming history.

Tracking Twitter in Syria's Day of Rage

There is no geo-tagged tweeting coming out of Syria, but today we are anticipating solidarity rallies in many Arab cities which we are tracking on twitter.



Beirut is the city closest to Syria, has the strongest ties, and has the most to gain or lose from the situation in Syria and we anticipate high tweeting the city today.



Tahrir as the de facto Capital of the Jasmine Revolt and we would expect to see solidarity protests there after prayers. In Cairo scores of over 80 are very high.



Kuwait is a major hub for tweeting and it will be interesting to see if levels raise above their normal highs in the 80s to 90s over protests for Syria.

The twitter hastag Syria is very active.
أخبار درعا وحوران
#Dsraa حوران : عاجل : تأكيد استشهاد عشرة شباب على جسر صيدا في مجزرة فك الحصار التي قامت بها قوات الغدر و...
»
shaamnews
شام - بانياس - أطفال جمعة الغضب 29-4 ج3
abdalrahman rabea
الأن حرر محضرك في أقرب كنيسة فهي بديل لأقسام الشرطة
Aisha Alsalloum
ودمعٌ لا يُكَفْكَفُ يا دمشقُ !*
Sherin M.
The attack on people in Sheikh Miskeen near has been described as a massacre.
Anas Qtiesh
Every Friday the protest in grow larger. Security forces kill more people. Tens of thousands are protesting today in multiple cities.
kurdish blogger
Syrian forces shoot villagers near Deraa -witnesses
Norm Gorton
"@: URGENT: Heavy fire by Syrian regime tanks now on area in " @-See what news looks like?
One reads many posts the reflect the feelings of the Egyptian Google Exec and Democracy hero Wael Ghonim that the Royal Wedding is at best a distraction. Sentiments expressing frustration that a non-story like a future constitutional monarch will get so much more press time than a massive day of Syrian protests is understandable.

Wael Ghonim
People's divorce from the regime in is way more important and noble than the .
Top Tweet
Blake Hounshell
While Britain celebrates Bashar al-Assad is hosting a mass funeral in .
Top Tweet
Goldie
12,000 journalists for . Thats more than and combined.
Top Tweet

But one can not say this is the main stream media or states, private people elect to twitter globally much more about the Royal Couple than Syria. But twitter does contain the criticism that too much media effort is being applied to the lesser of two stories. This is a critical media service by itself.


There are many youTube videos coming out from Syria now




We did have a stream that claims to be from Homs today inside of Syria. We can not confirm its origin though, but it has also gone down

Watch live streaming video from syriar at livestream.com

Popular Posts